Email Print   Text Size
Self Breast Exams Discouraged By Task Force

Posted:

Updated:

UPDATE: I-29 Re-Opened After Morning Crash
Icy road conditions led to a multi-car accident on Interstate 29 Tuesday morning.  It happened just outside of Sergeant Bluff, near the Sioux Gateway Airport.
More>>
Donations Needed for Haitian Earthquake Relief
Iowa Road Conditions
Popular links seen on Channel 9 Eyewitness News
Used Car Dealerships Taking Toyotas?
A massive recall is making it harder for people hoping to sell their Toyota, and some used car dealers are turning away Toyota trade–ins.
More>>
SC School District Announces Budget Plans for FY2011
Sioux City School budget could raise...along with your taxes
More>>
Firefighters, City Agree to New 3-Year Deal
City council members are giving Sioux City firefighters a raise.
More>>
Baby Thrown From Vehicle in Accident
A three month old baby girl who was thrown from a vehicle during an accident is out of the hospital.
More>>
Mark Becker Trial Delayed
Weather has postponed Mark Becker's jury selection until Wednesday
More>>

After being told the opposite for decades, this week women were told less mammograms are better and breast self exams do more harm than good. But medical professionals are speaking out, saying the choice should be yours.

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force released new guidelines recommending mammograms for woman ages 50-74, instead of 40 and up, only every other year. They also said no to self-exams.

The task force says self exams are not very effective at detecting cancer, and may induce panic in women who find lumps that may not be harmful to them.

Doctor Adnan Qalbani, a radiologist specialized in breast imaging, says self exams (which are free) and clinical exams (which are cheap) should not be tossed out.

“I don't know why you wouldn't do it...young women do have dense breasts and you find lumps and bumps that don't turn out to be anything. That's all true, but I think that collectively… our population is willing to accept a certain level of anxiety and a certain level of false positives, things that turn out to be cancers, in order to find those cancers earlier,” said Dr. Qalbani, who works at the Mercy Breast Care Center in Dakota Dunes.

Many health organizations, including the American Cancer Society and Susan G. Komen For The Cure, are still recommending self breast exams and routine mammograms for women ages 40 and up.

Dr. Qalbani recommends that women don't wait for what he calls ‘arbitrary’ ages to determine when you get your mammogram. He says talk with your doctor to figure out the best age for you.

We'll have more with Dr. Qalbani on Channel Nine Eyewitness News at Ten this Sunday for this week's Focus for the Cure.

All content © Copyright 2001 - 2010 WorldNow and KCAU-TV. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.